The most regulated unregulated market

Written by : Collections Posted on : 01/07/2020

The most regulated unregulated market- fantasies and hard legal realities of the art market
by Massimo Sterpi, partner, Co-chair of the IP department and Head of art law at Gianni Origoni Grippo Cappelli & Partners.

A Specter is haunting Europe, i.e. the entirely baseless claim that the art market is unregulated.
To the contrary, EU – and Italy in particular – have a range of laws making the art trade the most regulated market for movable properties. A brief summary of the legal framework in Italy can be quite telling:
– Acquisition from dealers is submitted to anti-money laundering rules and, for contemporary art, reported to collecting societies for the droit de suite;
– Any artwork or art collection beyond a certain age (70 years, or even 50, under certain circumstances) kept in Italy or being exported can be declared a national treasure (and then its movement, export and restoration must be authorised and the State has a right of first refusal on any sale);
– Capital gain obtained by selling an artwork is normally taxed (UK, France), whereas in Italy the situation is unclear, but taxation cannot be excluded;
– Detention of artworks abroad must be reported to Tax Authorities;
– And, finally, from the end of this year, first import into the EU shall be specifically authorised after demonstrating that the artwork was not exported illegally from the country of origin.
Do we need more?